Hear from Our Customers
Posted on Tracy MurrayJanuary 23, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Tina Vondane was super helpful from start to finish. She helped us transfer auto and home policies seamlessly. Very pleasant to work with.Posted on Craig BrunerJanuary 20, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Premier Choice is first rate. Kaitlyn was outstanding in addressing my request. Incredibly fast and thorough!Posted on Bernie RubinJanuary 20, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Shout out to Tina V. Thank you for your knowledge, professionalism and sincere commitment to help me through a somewhat difficult time in procuring auto insurance. What a pleasure not having to deal with "off-shore" customer service reps! Appreciate you. BPosted on Snow AliJanuary 18, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Amber Wallace was helpful, knowledgeable, and easy to work with. She made the whole process quick and I really appreciate it.Posted on Cody PaceJanuary 14, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Mike is great to work withPosted on Christy GrantJanuary 11, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Collecting a COI was a breeze. Thank you.Posted on Laura RoeJanuary 8, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Tina at Premier Choice Insurance was a delight! She got us a great quote on homeowners insurance and was able to save us almost $600 yearly. She was very personable and friendly. I am glad that we have switched our car insurance over and now our homeowners as well!Posted on Rachel GlaserJanuary 7, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Amber is great. She worked quickly to find us an insurance for our new home.Posted on L HutchJanuary 5, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Everyone is very helpful and a pleasure to work with! Thanks for all you do!Posted on Susan TurnerJanuary 4, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Premier Choice Insurance has been able to save me money on my Home Owners and Auto Policy, I'm so glad I switched! Thank you, Tina, for all your help, especially your Great communication and followup!
You’re not stuck with the company that just raised your rate by 50%. That’s the reality for thousands of Arizona homeowners right now—premiums jumping, coverage shrinking, and zero explanation beyond a renewal notice.
Here’s what changes when you work with us. You get access to over 40 top-rated insurance carriers, not just one. That means real competition for your business. Real options when your current insurer decides you’re not worth keeping. Real leverage when rates spike across the board.
Most San Tan Valley homeowners don’t realize they can get home insurance quotes from multiple companies in a single conversation. You’re not filling out forms on five different websites. You’re not waiting days for callbacks. You’re talking to someone local who knows which carriers are actually writing policies in Pinal County right now and which ones are worth your time.
The difference shows up in your premium, your coverage limits, and how fast someone picks up the phone when you need to file a claim.
We’ve been helping Arizona homeowners navigate this mess for years. We’re based in Mesa, family-owned, and we’ve built relationships with more than 100 insurance carriers so you don’t have to.
When State Farm or Allstate sends that non-renewal letter, we’re the call you make next. When your premium jumps 60% and you need house insurance quotes that actually make sense, we’re already pulling options before you finish explaining what happened.
We’ve earned over 930 five-star reviews on Google because we do what we say we’re going to do. We answer the phone. We show up. We don’t disappear after you sign the policy. And when wildfire risk or monsoon damage or construction costs drive rates up across San Tan Valley, AZ, we’re the ones finding you a better option while everyone else is sending cancellation notices.
First, you call or stop by our office. You’ll talk to a real person—not a chatbot, not a call center in another state. We ask about your home, your current coverage, and what just happened with your insurance company. Takes about ten minutes.
Then we run your information through our network of 40+ carriers. We’re looking for companies that are actively writing new homeowners insurance policies in San Tan Valley, that have competitive rates for your specific property, and that won’t bail on you after one claim. This happens while you’re still on the phone or within a few hours if we need more details.
You get real quotes with real numbers. Not estimates. Not ranges. Actual premiums with actual coverage limits so you can compare what you’re paying now to what you could be paying next month. We walk through each option, explain what’s different, and help you decide which one makes sense.
When you’re ready to switch, we handle the paperwork. We’ll even cancel your old policy for you at no cost. You’re covered, you’re saving money, and you’ve got a local agency that’ll be here when something goes wrong.
Ready to get started?
Standard homeowners insurance in Arizona covers your dwelling, your personal property, liability protection, and additional living expenses if you can’t stay in your home after a covered loss. That’s the baseline. But here’s what matters in San Tan Valley specifically.
Monsoon season hits hard here. Dust storms, flash flooding, wind damage—your policy needs to cover sudden water intrusion and wind-driven debris without a fight from your claims adjuster. Some carriers exclude or limit this coverage. We make sure yours doesn’t.
Wildfire risk is climbing across Pinal County. More than 15% of properties in Maricopa County are facing higher premiums or cancellations because of fire risk, and San Tan Valley isn’t immune. You need a carrier that’s not going to drop you the moment the wildfire maps get updated. We work with companies that understand Arizona’s risk profile and aren’t running for the exits.
Replacement cost matters more now than it did two years ago. Construction costs have spiked, and if your coverage limits haven’t kept up, you’re underinsured. We review your dwelling coverage to make sure it reflects what it would actually cost to rebuild your home today—not what you paid for it or what Zillow says it’s worth.
You also get options for things like equipment breakdown, water backup coverage, and higher limits on personal property. Most people don’t need every add-on, but you should know what’s available before your AC unit dies or your sewer backs up.
Arizona homeowners have seen rates climb 62.1% over the past five years—the highest increase in the country. That’s not a billing error. It’s a market-wide correction driven by wildfire risk, monsoon damage, and construction costs that have nearly doubled since 2020.
Insurance companies are paying out more in claims than they’re collecting in premiums. When that happens, they either raise rates or stop writing new policies altogether. You’re seeing both. Carriers like State Farm and Allstate have limited new business in Arizona, and existing customers are getting hit with 20%, 30%, even 50% increases at renewal.
The key is to shop your policy before your renewal hits. If you wait until after the increase takes effect, you’ve already lost leverage. Get homeowner insurance quotes from multiple carriers now, compare what’s available, and switch if it makes sense. Loyalty doesn’t pay when your insurer is raising your rate faster than inflation.
The average homeowners insurance premium in Arizona is around $1,991 per year, which is still below the national average of $2,423. But averages don’t tell you much. Your actual rate depends on your home’s age, size, construction type, claims history, and which carrier you’re using.
In San Tan Valley, you’ll see quotes ranging from $1,200 to $3,000+ annually for similar homes. The spread comes down to how each insurance company evaluates risk in Pinal County. Some carriers price wildfire exposure aggressively. Others focus on monsoon claims or roof age. A few are actively trying to grow their book of business here and are pricing competitively to attract new customers.
That’s why getting house insurance quotes from multiple companies matters. One carrier might quote you $2,400 while another comes in at $1,600 for the same coverage. You won’t know unless you compare. And if you’re only talking to one agent who represents one company, you’re leaving money on the table.
Non-renewals are spiking in Arizona, especially in areas with elevated wildfire risk. If your insurer decides not to renew your policy, they’ll send you a notice—usually 30 to 120 days before your renewal date depending on the reason. You’re not dropped immediately, but you need to find new coverage before that deadline or you’ll have a lapse.
A lapse in coverage is a problem. It makes you a higher risk to other insurers, which means higher premiums or outright denials. If you have a mortgage, your lender will force-place coverage on your home, and that policy will cost two to three times what you’d pay on the open market with worse coverage.
The move here is to start shopping as soon as you get that non-renewal notice. Don’t wait. Don’t assume it’ll be easy to replace. Call us—we work with multiple carriers and can place you with a company that’s actually writing new business in San Tan Valley, AZ. We do this every week. You get quoted, covered, and moved over before your current policy expires.
If you go directly to a company like Geico home insurance or Progressive home insurance, you get one quote from one carrier. That’s it. If their rate is high or they won’t cover your home, you start over with the next company. You’re doing the legwork, filling out forms, waiting for callbacks, and hoping one of them comes back with something reasonable.
We work with 40+ insurance carriers. You give us your information once, and we shop it across our entire network. You get multiple home insurance quotes in one conversation. We know which companies are competitive in San Tan Valley right now, which ones are restricting new policies, and which ones have the best claims service when something goes wrong.
You’re not paying extra for this. We get paid by the insurance company, not by you. Our job is to find you the best coverage at the best price, and we don’t have a quota to hit with any single carrier. If your current insurer is overcharging you, we’ll tell you. If switching doesn’t make sense, we’ll tell you that too.
Monsoon damage is typically covered under a standard homeowners insurance policy, but it depends on what caused the damage. Wind damage, hail, and debris impact are covered. Water damage from rain getting in through a wind-damaged roof is covered. But flooding—water coming up from the ground or through your doors—is not. You need separate flood insurance for that.
Wildfire coverage is included in most policies as part of your dwelling and personal property protection. If a wildfire destroys your home, your homeowners insurance should cover the rebuild and your belongings up to your policy limits. The issue isn’t whether it’s covered—it’s whether your insurer will keep you after you file a claim or even before if they decide your area is too high-risk.
That’s why working with us matters. If your current carrier drops you because of wildfire risk, we’ve already got relationships with other companies that are still writing policies in fire-prone areas. You’re not starting from scratch. You’re moving to a carrier that understands Arizona and isn’t going to leave you uninsured the moment the risk maps change.
Cheap and adequate aren’t opposites. You can absolutely find affordable homeowners insurance or renters insurance without gutting your coverage, but it takes some work. The trick is knowing where to look and what to adjust.
Start by comparing quotes from multiple carriers. Rates vary wildly between companies for the same coverage. One insurer might charge you $2,000 while another charges $1,400 for identical limits. You won’t find that savings unless you shop around. Raising your deductible from $1,000 to $2,500 can drop your premium by 15% to 25%. If you’ve got an emergency fund and can handle a higher out-of-pocket cost after a claim, that’s an easy way to cut your rate without cutting coverage.
Bundling your home insurance with your auto policy usually gets you a discount with most carriers. Ask about other discounts too—security systems, fire alarms, claims-free history, and even paying your premium in full upfront can shave another 5% to 10% off. But don’t chase discounts at the expense of coverage. If you’re underinsured and your home gets damaged, saving $200 a year won’t matter when you’re $50,000 short on your rebuild.
Other Services we provide in San Tan Valley