Hear from Our Customers
Posted on Tracy MurrayJanuary 23, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Tina Vondane was super helpful from start to finish. She helped us transfer auto and home policies seamlessly. Very pleasant to work with.Posted on Craig BrunerJanuary 20, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Premier Choice is first rate. Kaitlyn was outstanding in addressing my request. Incredibly fast and thorough!Posted on Bernie RubinJanuary 20, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Shout out to Tina V. Thank you for your knowledge, professionalism and sincere commitment to help me through a somewhat difficult time in procuring auto insurance. What a pleasure not having to deal with "off-shore" customer service reps! Appreciate you. BPosted on Snow AliJanuary 18, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Amber Wallace was helpful, knowledgeable, and easy to work with. She made the whole process quick and I really appreciate it.Posted on Cody PaceJanuary 14, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Mike is great to work withPosted on Christy GrantJanuary 11, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Collecting a COI was a breeze. Thank you.Posted on Laura RoeJanuary 8, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Tina at Premier Choice Insurance was a delight! She got us a great quote on homeowners insurance and was able to save us almost $600 yearly. She was very personable and friendly. I am glad that we have switched our car insurance over and now our homeowners as well!Posted on Rachel GlaserJanuary 7, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Amber is great. She worked quickly to find us an insurance for our new home.Posted on L HutchJanuary 5, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Everyone is very helpful and a pleasure to work with! Thanks for all you do!Posted on Susan TurnerJanuary 4, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Premier Choice Insurance has been able to save me money on my Home Owners and Auto Policy, I'm so glad I switched! Thank you, Tina, for all your help, especially your Great communication and followup!
Most people stick with the same auto insurance company for years. Then the rate jumps after one claim, or you realize your coverage has gaps you never knew existed. By the time you’re shopping around, you’re doing it under pressure.
Here’s what changes when you work with an independent agency. You get access to over 40 top-rated carriers—Progressive, GEICO, USAA, AAA, and dozens more—without filling out the same form over and over. We run your information once and show you what’s actually available in Glendale, AZ.
That means you’re comparing real options side by side. Not just price, but coverage quality, claims reputation, and how each carrier handles Arizona-specific risks like monsoon damage or uninsured drivers. You’re not guessing whether you could do better somewhere else. You’re seeing it.
And if you decide to switch, we handle the cancellation of your old policy. No awkward phone calls. No overlap charges. Just a clean transition to coverage that actually fits.
We’re a family-owned independent agency serving Glendale and the greater Phoenix area. We’ve built our reputation on being the kind of agency that picks up the phone—and actually knows who you are when you call.
We’re not tied to one carrier. That’s the whole point. We represent over 40 auto insurance companies, which means we work for you, not them. Our job is to find the policy that makes sense for your situation, your budget, and your coverage needs.
We’ve earned over 930 five-star reviews and recognition as Agents of the Year because we treat insurance like a conversation, not a transaction. You’re not talking to a call center in another state. You’re working with people who understand what it’s like to drive in Arizona—and what it takes to protect yourself here.
First, we talk. You tell us what you’re currently paying, what coverage you have, and whether you’ve had any claims or changes recently. This takes about ten minutes, and it’s not a sales pitch—it’s just information gathering.
Then we run your profile through our network of carriers. That includes the big names like Progressive Insurance, GEICO car insurance, USAA insurance, Direct Auto, and AAA insurance, plus regional carriers that often beat the national guys on price or service. We’re looking at liability limits, comprehensive and collision coverage, deductibles, and discounts you actually qualify for.
Once we have the quotes, we walk you through them. We’ll tell you why one policy might cost less but leave you exposed, or why another might be worth the extra $20 a month. We’re not pushing the highest commission—we’re explaining the trade-offs so you can make the call.
If you want to move forward, we set everything up. That includes canceling your old policy if you want us to, so you’re not paying for two policies at once or dealing with lapsed coverage. The whole process usually wraps up in a few days, and you’ve got our number if anything comes up after that.
Ready to get started?
Cheap car insurance sounds great until you file a claim and realize what you’re missing. The goal isn’t just low premiums—it’s the right coverage at a price that doesn’t make you wince every six months.
In Glendale, AZ, that means thinking about more than state minimums. Arizona requires liability coverage, but the minimum limits won’t come close to covering a serious accident. You’re also dealing with one of the highest rates of uninsured drivers in the country, which makes uninsured motorist coverage worth considering. Comprehensive coverage matters here too—monsoon season, hail, and even wildfire smoke can damage your vehicle in ways that liability won’t touch.
When we compare auto insurance companies for you, we’re looking at how each one handles these scenarios. Some carriers offer better rates for clean driving records. Others are more forgiving if you’ve had a lapse in coverage or a recent claim. A few specialize in high-risk drivers or offer discounts for bundling home and auto.
We also look at claims service. A low rate doesn’t help much if the company drags out your claim for months or lowballs the repair estimate. We know which carriers have strong reputations in Arizona and which ones people end up leaving after their first claim. That context matters when you’re deciding where to put your money.
When you go directly to a company like Progressive Insurance or GEICO, you’re only seeing their rates and their coverage options. That’s fine if they happen to be the best fit for you, but you won’t know unless you repeat the process with five or six other companies.
An independent agency like ours represents multiple carriers. We can quote you with Progressive, GEICO, USAA, AAA, Direct Auto Insurance, and 35+ others in one conversation. You’re comparing apples to apples without spending your afternoon on hold or filling out the same form over and over.
The other advantage is ongoing support. If you buy a policy directly and need to file a claim or adjust your coverage, you’re calling a 1-800 number. When you work with us, you’re calling someone who already knows your situation and can walk you through the process or advocate on your behalf if something goes sideways.
The only way to know for sure is to compare rates from multiple auto insurance companies. The “cheapest” carrier changes depending on your age, driving record, vehicle type, credit score, and even your ZIP code within Glendale, AZ.
For example, USAA car insurance tends to offer great rates for military members and their families, but you have to be eligible. Progressive Insurance often beats competitors for drivers with a ticket or accident on their record. AAA insurance might come out ahead if you’re bundling policies or you’re an older driver with a clean history.
We run your information through 40+ carriers to find out who’s actually competitive for your specific profile. Sometimes the difference is $30 a month. Sometimes it’s $100. And sometimes the cheapest option leaves you underinsured, which is why we also explain what you’re giving up if you go with the lowest bid. The goal is the best value, not just the lowest number.
Yes. You can switch car insurance anytime—you’re not locked in for the full six or twelve months. Most people don’t realize that.
If you cancel mid-term, your current carrier will refund the unused portion of your premium. We can handle that cancellation for you so you don’t have to make the call yourself. We’ll also make sure your new policy starts the same day your old one ends, so there’s no gap in coverage or overlap where you’re paying twice.
The one thing to watch for is cancellation fees, but most major carriers don’t charge them anymore. If yours does, we’ll let you know upfront so you can decide whether switching now makes sense or if you’d rather wait until your renewal. Either way, you’re not stuck just because you prepaid for the year.
Your new policy covers you the same way your old one did—assuming you chose similar coverage levels. The carrier doesn’t penalize you for being new to them. Claims are handled based on the terms of your policy, not how long you’ve been a customer.
That said, this is where working with a local agency makes a difference. If you bought your policy online and need to file a claim, you’re navigating that process alone. When you’re working with us, you can call and we’ll walk you through what to report, what documentation you need, and what to expect from the claims adjuster.
We’ve also been doing this long enough to know which carriers in Arizona handle claims well and which ones people regret choosing. That’s part of why we don’t just show you the cheapest option—we show you the ones that will actually take care of you when it matters. A claim is stressful enough without fighting your insurance company at the same time.
No. There’s no cost to you for our service. We’re paid by the insurance carriers when you choose a policy through us, the same way a direct agent at Progressive or GEICO gets paid. You’re not paying extra for access to multiple companies—you’re just getting more options in one place.
In fact, the rates we quote are the same rates you’d get if you went directly to each carrier yourself. Insurance premiums are regulated, so an independent agency can’t mark them up. The difference is we do the shopping for you and explain what you’re actually buying.
Some people assume there’s a catch, but there isn’t. We make money when you choose a policy, so our incentive is to find you something you’ll actually stick with. If we put you in the wrong coverage or overpromise to close a deal, you’ll leave at renewal and we’ll lose that income. Our business is built on keeping clients long-term, which only happens if we get it right the first time.
Most experts say every one to three years, but the real answer is whenever your situation changes. If you’ve moved, bought a new car, added a driver, paid off your loan, or had a ticket fall off your record, your rate could shift significantly.
You should also shop around if your premium jumps at renewal without explanation. A lot of carriers raise rates after the first term, betting you won’t notice or won’t bother switching. If your rate goes up more than 10% and you haven’t filed a claim, that’s a good time to see what else is out there.
The nice thing about working with an independent agency is you don’t have to do this yourself every time. We can re-shop your policy at renewal and let you know if there’s a better option. If your current carrier is still competitive, we’ll tell you that too. You’re not starting from scratch every year—you’ve got someone keeping an eye on it for you.
Other Services we provide in Glendale