Hear from Our Customers
Your current insurer just hit you with a 60% rate increase. Or they dropped you entirely after one claim. Now you’re scrambling to find homeowners insurance that doesn’t cost more than your mortgage payment.
Here’s what changes when you work with an independent agency. You’re not stuck with one company’s answer. We represent over 40 carriers, which means when one says no or quotes you an absurd number, we’ve got 39 other options to check. That’s the difference between panic-shopping on your own and having someone who knows which carriers are actually writing policies in Goodyear right now.
You get home insurance quotes from multiple companies in one conversation. No filling out the same information on six different websites. No waiting for callbacks that never come. Just real options, explained clearly, so you can make a decision based on coverage and cost that actually makes sense for your home.
We’ve been serving Arizona homeowners since 2015. We’re a family-owned agency based in Mesa, and we’ve watched the home insurance market in this state go from stable to chaotic in just a few years.
We’ve seen the rate increases. Arizona home insurance jumped 62.1% over five years—the highest in the country. We’ve seen major carriers like State Farm stop writing new policies. We’ve talked to Goodyear residents who got rejection letters from 15 companies before finding coverage.
That’s exactly why independent agencies matter right now. We’re not tied to one company’s underwriting decisions or rate hikes. When the market shifts, we shift with it. Our 930+ five-star Google reviews come from people who were in your exact situation and needed someone local who could actually pick up the phone and help.
First, we talk. You tell us about your home, your current situation, and what happened with your last insurer. If you got dropped or hit with a massive increase, we need to know why. That context matters when we’re shopping your policy.
Then we quote. We run your information through our network of 40+ carriers to see who’s writing policies in Goodyear and what they’re charging. Some carriers won’t touch certain areas due to wildfire risk—Risk Factor estimates 91% of Goodyear properties will be affected by wildfires in the next 30 years. We know which companies care about that and which don’t.
You get options, not pressure. We’ll show you three to five real quotes with different coverage levels and price points. We’ll explain what you’re actually buying with each one. Then you decide. Once you pick a policy, we handle the paperwork and cancel your old coverage if needed. You don’t pay us anything extra—carriers pay our commission, so our service costs you nothing.
Ready to get started?
Goodyear sits in an interesting spot for home insurance. Crime rates here run at or below state averages, which helps keep costs reasonable compared to other parts of the Valley. You get nearly 300 sunny days a year, but that Arizona sun does real damage to roofs over time—and carriers know it.
Wildfire risk is the bigger conversation. More than 15% of Maricopa County properties face higher premiums or cancellations due to wildfire exposure. That doesn’t mean you can’t get covered in Goodyear. It means you need an agent who knows which carriers are still writing policies here and what they require for coverage.
Standard homeowners insurance should cover your dwelling, personal property, liability, and additional living expenses if you can’t stay in your home after a covered loss. But “standard” varies wildly right now. Some policies exclude certain roof damage. Others cap payouts on older homes. We make sure you understand exactly what you’re buying before you sign anything.
If you’re also looking at renters insurance or bundling options, we handle those too. Progressive home insurance, Geico home insurance, and dozens of other carriers are in our network. The goal is finding the right home insurance company for your specific property and situation, not just the cheapest quote that leaves you underinsured.
Arizona saw the fourth-biggest home insurance rate increase in the country in 2024 at 11.4%. Over the past five years, rates jumped 62.1%—the highest increase of any state during that period. That’s not just inflation. Construction costs in Arizona have outpaced national inflation significantly. Catastrophe exposure from wildfires and severe monsoon storms keeps climbing. And the reinsurance market—basically, insurance for insurance companies—has gotten extremely expensive.
Your specific rate increase might also be tied to your home’s age, your roof condition, your claims history, or your carrier’s decision to exit certain risk areas. Some companies are pulling back from Arizona entirely or restricting new policies to lower-risk areas. If you’ve been with the same insurer for 15+ years, they may have been absorbing costs for a while and finally passed them on to you all at once.
The frustrating part is that Arizona’s average home insurance cost is still below the national average—$1,991 versus $2,423 nationally. But that doesn’t help when your personal rate just doubled. That’s when shopping with an independent agent who can compare 40+ carriers makes a real difference.
First, don’t panic. You’re not alone. Some Goodyear homeowners have been rejected by 20+ companies before finding coverage. The key is working with someone who knows which carriers are still actively writing policies in your area and what they’re looking for.
Start by understanding why you were cancelled. Was it a claims issue? Roof age? Wildfire risk zone? Non-renewal due to company policy changes? The reason matters because it tells us which carriers might still cover you. If your cancellation was due to wildfire exposure, we know which companies are still writing in those areas and what mitigation steps might help you qualify.
Get quotes from at least three insurers before making a decision—and do it quickly. If you have a mortgage, your lender requires continuous coverage. Let that lapse and they’ll force-place a policy that costs significantly more and covers significantly less. We handle the urgency of this situation regularly. We’ll run your information through our carrier network, find your options, and help you get covered before your cancellation date hits. We also provide free policy cancellation service for your old coverage once your new policy is active.
The average homeowners insurance premium in Arizona is around $1,991 per year, but that’s just a starting point. Your actual cost depends on your home’s age, size, construction type, roof condition, coverage limits, deductible, claims history, and credit score. In Goodyear specifically, you might pay less than the state average if your home is newer and in a lower-risk area, or more if you’re in a wildfire exposure zone.
Here’s what’s really happening with costs right now. Arizona home insurance rates increased 71% from 2020 to 2025—sixth highest in the country. Meanwhile, inflation over that same period was only 26.4%. That’s a 44.6 percentage point gap between premium hikes and actual inflation, which is the sixth-largest gap nationwide. Insurance companies are pricing in future risk, not just current costs.
The best way to know what you’ll actually pay is to get real quotes based on your specific property. That’s where having access to 40+ carriers helps. One company might quote you $3,200 a year while another quotes $1,850 for similar coverage. We find those gaps and show you where the value is. Cost matters, but so does coverage adequacy and the company’s reputation for paying claims. Cheap renters insurance or homeowner insurance quotes don’t help if the company denies your claim when you need it most.
Standard homeowners insurance typically covers four main areas: your dwelling (the physical structure), your personal property (belongings inside), liability protection (if someone gets hurt on your property), and additional living expenses (hotel costs if your home is uninhabitable after a covered loss). But “standard” has gotten complicated in Arizona’s current market.
Covered perils usually include fire, lightning, windstorms, hail, theft, vandalism, and water damage from burst pipes. What’s often excluded: flood damage, earthquake damage, normal wear and tear, and sometimes specific roof damage if your roof is over a certain age. Some carriers are now adding wildfire exclusions or limitations in high-risk areas. Others are capping payouts on older homes or requiring higher deductibles for wind and hail claims.
Arizona-specific risks you need to think about: monsoon damage, roof deterioration from extreme heat and UV exposure, and wildfire exposure even if you’re not in a mountain area. Make sure your policy includes replacement cost coverage for your dwelling and personal property, not actual cash value, which depreciates over time. Ask about coverage for detached structures like sheds or casitas, and confirm your liability limits are high enough—$300,000 minimum, $500,000 is better. We walk through all of this when we quote your policy so you know exactly what you’re getting.
Bundling can save you money—usually 10% to 25% off your total premium—but it’s not always the best move. Sometimes you’ll get a better overall price by splitting your home and auto coverage between two different carriers. The only way to know for sure is to run the numbers both ways.
Here’s when bundling makes sense: when the discount is substantial and both policies offer solid coverage at competitive rates. If you’re with a carrier that’s great for auto but mediocre for homeowners, that bundle discount might not offset the higher base rate on your home insurance. Or if one company offers way better coverage terms for your home, it might be worth paying a bit more overall to get that protection.
We represent 40+ top-rated carriers for both home and auto insurance, so we can show you bundled quotes and separate quotes side by side. You’ll see the actual dollar difference and can decide what makes sense. Some of our clients save $800 a year by bundling. Others save more by splitting coverage. We’re not pushing you toward one answer—we’re showing you the math so you can choose based on real numbers, not guesswork. And if your situation changes down the road, we’re here to re-shop your coverage and make sure you’re still getting the best value.
When you go directly to a company—whether that’s Progressive home insurance, Geico home insurance, State Farm, or anyone else—you get one answer. That company either covers you at their price or they don’t. If they say no or quote you a number that doesn’t work, you start over with the next company. After the third or fourth website form, you’re exhausted and you just pick whoever said yes.
Independent agents flip that process. We work for you, not the insurance company. We have access to 40+ carriers, so when we run your information, we’re checking multiple companies at once. One conversation gets you three to five real quotes. If one carrier won’t cover you due to wildfire risk or roof age, we already know which other carriers will. You’re not getting rejected and starting over—we’re doing that legwork behind the scenes.
The other advantage is ongoing service. If you buy directly from a company and need to file a claim or change your coverage, you’re calling a 1-800 number and talking to whoever answers in whatever call center they’re using that day. When you work with us, you call our Goodyear office and talk to the same people who wrote your policy. We’re here when your situation changes, when you have questions, and when you need someone to actually advocate for you during a claim. Our service costs you nothing extra—we get paid by the carriers—so you’re getting more options and better support at the same price you’d pay going direct.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in Goodyear
