Hear from Our Customers
You get access to over 100 insurance companies without making 100 phone calls. That includes carriers like Progressive Insurance, GEICO car insurance, USAA insurance, AAA insurance, and Direct Auto Insurance—plus dozens of regional carriers that often beat the big names on price and coverage.
We’re not tied to one company. That means we can tell you the truth about what’s actually cheap car insurance versus what just looks cheap until you file a claim.
You also get someone local who picks up the phone. Not a call center in another state. Not an automated system that makes you repeat your policy number four times. A real person in Arizona who knows what’s happening with insurance rates here and can explain why your premium went up 40% last year even though you didn’t file a claim.
Most people don’t realize that staying loyal to one insurance company often costs them more than switching. Carriers count on inertia. We count on giving you enough information to make the call yourself.
We’re a family-owned independent agency based in Arizona. We’ve been helping people across the state—including St. Johns, AZ—find coverage that actually works when they need it. We’re not the biggest agency, but we’re not trying to be.
What we are is accessible. We’ve earned over 930 five-star Google reviews because we show up, answer questions, and don’t disappear after you sign. We were named Agents of the Year in 2023 and recognized as Three Best Rated Insurance Agents in Mesa, but the real credential is whether we pick up when you call.
St. Johns sits in Apache County, where weather, wildfire risk, and rural property considerations make insurance more complicated than it is in metro Phoenix. We work with carriers who understand that, and we help you avoid the ones who don’t.
First, we ask about your current coverage and what’s driving you to shop. If it’s a rate increase, we want to know how much. If it’s a claim issue, we want to know what happened. That context matters because it tells us which carriers will actually want your business and which ones will just waste your time.
Then we run quotes across our network of over 100 insurance companies. We’re looking at auto, home, umbrella, and commercial depending on what you need. For most people in St. Johns, bundling home and auto makes sense—but not always, and we’ll tell you either way.
Once we find coverage that beats what you have now, we walk you through the differences. Not just price, but what’s covered, what’s excluded, and how claims are handled. You’re not signing anything until you understand what you’re buying.
After that, we handle the switch. That includes canceling your old policy if you want us to—no charge for that service. We also stay in touch when your situation changes, whether that’s adding a driver, buying a new car, or dealing with a claim.
Ready to get started?
When you compare insurance companies, you’re not just comparing price. You’re comparing how claims get handled, whether you’ll get OEM parts or aftermarket, and if your agent will still return your calls two years from now.
In St. Johns, AZ, homeowners insurance is tricky. You’re in a rural area with wildfire exposure, which means some carriers won’t write new policies here at all. Others will, but they’ll exclude fire coverage or charge rates that don’t make sense. We work with carriers who actually insure properties in Apache County without carve-outs that gut your coverage.
For auto insurance, you’ll see quotes from Progressive Insurance, GEICO, USAA (if you’re eligible), AAA Insurance, and Direct Auto Insurance Company. You’ll also see quotes from carriers you’ve never heard of that often beat the household names. We represent over 40 top-rated auto insurance carriers, and that range matters because the “cheapest” option depends entirely on your profile.
If you own a business in St. Johns—whether that’s a ranch, a retail shop, or a contracting company—we also handle commercial coverage. That’s liability, property, workers’ comp, and commercial auto. Most business owners in rural Arizona are underinsured because they’re working with agents who don’t understand the exposure.
Arizona home insurance rates jumped 62% over the past five years—the highest increase in the country. In 2024 alone, rates went up another 11.4%. That’s being driven by wildfire risk, population growth, increased claims, and carriers pulling out of the state entirely.
For auto insurance, you’re seeing similar pressure. More people moving to Arizona means more traffic and more accidents. That pushes up claims costs, and carriers pass that on to you. Even if your driving record is clean, your rates are climbing because the overall risk pool is getting more expensive to insure.
The other issue is loyalty penalties. If you’ve been with the same insurance company for years, you’re probably paying more than a new customer would for the same coverage. Carriers bank on you not shopping around. That’s why over 50% of Arizona consumers are actively shopping for insurance every year now—they’ve figured out that staying put costs them money.
A captive agent works for one insurance company. If you talk to a State Farm agent, they can only sell you State Farm. Same with Allstate, Farmers, or any other single-company agent. That’s fine if that one company happens to have the best rate and coverage for you—but you won’t know unless you shop around.
An independent agent like us works with over 100 insurance companies. We’re not tied to any single carrier, so we can show you quotes from Progressive, GEICO, USAA, AAA, and dozens of others in one conversation. If one carrier doesn’t want your business or quotes you a ridiculous rate, we move to the next one.
The other advantage is that we can tell you the truth. If a carrier has a reputation for dragging out claims or denying coverage on technicalities, we know—and we’ll steer you away from them. Captive agents can’t do that because they only have one option to sell you.
Cheap car insurance isn’t always a good deal. If you’re only carrying state minimum liability limits, you’re technically insured—but you’re not protected. Arizona requires 25/50/15 coverage, which means $25,000 per person for injuries, $50,000 per accident, and $15,000 for property damage. That sounds like a lot until you cause an accident that totals someone’s $60,000 truck and sends two people to the hospital.
The real question is whether your coverage will actually pay out when you need it. Some carriers advertise low rates but use aftermarket parts, apply betterment deductions, or fight every claim. You save $30 a month, then get stuck with a $5,000 bill after an accident because your policy didn’t cover what you thought it did.
When we quote you, we’re looking at the full picture: your liability limits, your deductibles, whether you have uninsured motorist coverage, and how the carrier handles claims. Sometimes the cheapest option is the right one. Other times, spending an extra $20 a month saves you thousands later. We’ll walk you through the difference so you can decide.
Yes, and bundling usually saves you money—but not always. Some carriers offer big discounts when you combine home and auto. Others barely budge. It depends on the carrier, your property, and your driving record.
In St. Johns, AZ, the bigger issue is finding a carrier that will insure your home at all. You’re in Apache County, which has wildfire exposure. Some insurance companies have stopped writing new homeowners policies in high-risk areas, and others exclude fire coverage entirely. If you’re stuck with a carrier that won’t budge on price, bundling your auto with them might not save you anything.
What we do is quote your home and auto separately, then quote them bundled across multiple carriers. That way you can see the actual savings instead of assuming bundling is always the best move. Sometimes you’re better off splitting your coverage between two carriers. Sometimes one carrier beats everyone on both. We’ll show you the numbers either way.
If your carrier non-renews you, it’s usually because of claims, a lapse in payment, or because they’re pulling out of your area entirely. In Arizona, carriers have been dropping homeowners policies in high-risk wildfire zones, and some are getting more aggressive about non-renewing auto policies after even one at-fault accident.
The good news is that getting dropped by one insurance company doesn’t mean you can’t get coverage somewhere else. It might mean you’ll pay more, or it might mean you need to work with a different type of carrier. We have access to non-standard and high-risk carriers that specialize in insuring people who’ve been non-renewed or canceled.
The key is not waiting until the last minute. If you get a non-renewal notice, call us right away. We need time to shop your options and find coverage before your current policy expires. If you let it lapse, you’ll be considered high-risk even if the non-renewal wasn’t your fault, and that makes everything more expensive.
An umbrella policy covers you when your auto or homeowners liability limits run out. If you cause a serious accident and get sued for $500,000, but your auto policy only covers $100,000, you’re personally on the hook for the other $400,000. An umbrella policy kicks in and covers that gap.
Most people don’t think they need one until they get sued. But if you own property, have savings, or earn a decent income, you’re a target in a lawsuit. Arizona is a litigious state, and injury attorneys know how to find out what you’re worth. If you’re worth suing, you need an umbrella policy.
The cost is usually around $200 to $400 a year for $1 million in coverage. That’s cheap compared to what you’d lose in a lawsuit. We typically recommend umbrella coverage if you own a home, have teenage drivers, own rental property, or have assets you’d rather not lose. It’s not required, but it’s one of those things that makes a massive difference if you ever actually need it.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in St. Johns
