Hear from Our Customers
Posted on Tracy MurrayJanuary 23, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Tina Vondane was super helpful from start to finish. She helped us transfer auto and home policies seamlessly. Very pleasant to work with.Posted on Craig BrunerJanuary 20, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Premier Choice is first rate. Kaitlyn was outstanding in addressing my request. Incredibly fast and thorough!Posted on Bernie RubinJanuary 20, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Shout out to Tina V. Thank you for your knowledge, professionalism and sincere commitment to help me through a somewhat difficult time in procuring auto insurance. What a pleasure not having to deal with "off-shore" customer service reps! Appreciate you. BPosted on Snow AliJanuary 18, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Amber Wallace was helpful, knowledgeable, and easy to work with. She made the whole process quick and I really appreciate it.Posted on Cody PaceJanuary 14, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Mike is great to work withPosted on Christy GrantJanuary 11, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Collecting a COI was a breeze. Thank you.Posted on Laura RoeJanuary 8, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Tina at Premier Choice Insurance was a delight! She got us a great quote on homeowners insurance and was able to save us almost $600 yearly. She was very personable and friendly. I am glad that we have switched our car insurance over and now our homeowners as well!Posted on Rachel GlaserJanuary 7, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Amber is great. She worked quickly to find us an insurance for our new home.Posted on L HutchJanuary 5, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Everyone is very helpful and a pleasure to work with! Thanks for all you do!Posted on Susan TurnerJanuary 4, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Premier Choice Insurance has been able to save me money on my Home Owners and Auto Policy, I'm so glad I switched! Thank you, Tina, for all your help, especially your Great communication and followup!
You’ve been with the same company for years. Then your rate jumps 30% with no explanation. Or worse—you file one claim and suddenly you’re getting non-renewed.
That’s not loyalty. That’s being stuck.
Here’s what changes when you work with us: you get access to dozens of insurance companies at once. Progressive insurance, GEICO car insurance, USAA insurance, AAA insurance, Direct Auto, and 35+ others. All compared side-by-side based on your actual needs and driving record. You’re not locked into one company’s pricing or underwriting mood swings. If one carrier raises your rates, we move you to another. If you file a claim and get dropped, we find you coverage the same day.
No more calling around to get quotes. No more wondering if you’re missing a better deal. You tell us what you need once, and we handle the rest.
We’re based in Mesa and serve the entire Valley, including Litchfield Park and the West Valley. Family-owned, locally operated, and we actually pick up the phone when you call.
We’ve been doing this long enough to know what matters: straight answers, fair pricing, and someone who shows up when things go wrong. That’s why we’ve earned over 930 five-star reviews on Google and recognition as Three Best Rated Insurance Agents in Mesa.
Litchfield Park residents deal with the same insurance headaches as everyone else in Arizona—monsoon damage, hail claims, wildfire risk zones, and carriers pulling out of the state. We know how to navigate it because we live here too. When your roof gets pummeled or your car gets totaled on the 303, you’ll have a local agent who knows your name and can walk you through what happens next.
First, we talk. You tell us what you’re paying now, what coverage you have, and what’s frustrating you about your current setup. Takes about 10 minutes.
Then we shop. We run your information through our network of 40+ carriers—everything from the big names like Progressive Insurance Company and GEICO to regional carriers you’ve probably never heard of but who might offer better rates for your situation. We’re looking at cheap car insurance options, yes, but also coverage quality. Low price doesn’t help if the company denies your claim or takes three months to pay out.
Finally, we present your options. You’ll see real quotes with real coverage details. We explain what each policy actually covers, where the gaps are, and what we’d recommend based on your situation. If you want to switch, we handle the paperwork and even cancel your old policy for you. If your current carrier is actually your best option, we’ll tell you that too.
Ready to get started?
Arizona isn’t a cheap state to insure. Litchfield Park sits in a hail zone. Summer monsoons cause millions in damage every year. Uninsured driver rates are higher than the national average. Your policy needs to account for all of that.
For auto insurance, you need more than state minimums. Arizona only requires $25,000 per person for injury liability—that won’t cover a serious accident. We typically recommend at least $100,000/$300,000 in liability coverage, plus uninsured motorist protection and comprehensive coverage for weather damage. USAA car insurance is great if you’re military or a veteran. Direct Auto Insurance Company works well for drivers with less-than-perfect records. Progressive and GEICO are solid mid-range options for clean driving histories.
For homeowners insurance, focus on dwelling coverage that actually reflects replacement cost. Building materials are expensive right now, and if your home is totaled, you don’t want to find out your policy only covers 80% of what it costs to rebuild. We also recommend higher wind and hail deductibles to keep premiums manageable, plus coverage for monsoon-related water damage. AAA insurance offers solid bundling discounts if you’re already a member.
If you own rental property, have teenage drivers, or run a business out of your home, you’ll need additional coverage. Most people don’t realize their standard homeowners policy won’t cover business equipment or liability. That’s where umbrella policies and commercial riders come in.
We have direct contracts with over 40 insurance companies, which means we can quote you through all of them without you having to contact each one individually. When you give us your information, we enter it into each carrier’s system and pull real quotes based on their current rates and underwriting guidelines.
This isn’t an estimate or a ballpark figure. These are actual bindable quotes you can purchase today. The process takes us about 20 minutes on our end, but it saves you hours of calling around or filling out forms on different websites.
The advantage is that we know which companies are competitive for different risk profiles. If you have a ticket on your record, we know which carriers won’t penalize you as hard. If you have a new roof, we know which companies give the biggest discounts. That’s information you won’t get from a captive agent who only sells one brand.
Cheap car insurance is worth it if the coverage is solid and the company actually pays claims. It’s not worth it if you’re just buying state minimums from a carrier with a reputation for dragging out claims or denying coverage on technicalities.
Here’s the distinction: low price because of good underwriting and efficient operations? That’s fine. Low price because they’re cutting corners on coverage or customer service? That’s a problem waiting to happen.
We’ve seen people save $40 a month switching to a budget carrier, then get hit with a $15,000 out-of-pocket bill when their policy didn’t cover something they assumed it would. The goal isn’t the cheapest policy—it’s the best value. That means adequate liability limits, comprehensive and collision coverage if your car is worth protecting, and a company that will actually answer the phone when you need to file a claim. Sometimes that’s a budget carrier. Sometimes it’s not.
They all offer similar core coverage, but they price risk differently and serve different customer bases. Progressive Insurance tends to be competitive for drivers with tickets or accidents because they specialize in non-standard risk. GEICO car insurance usually offers good rates for clean driving records and military families. USAA insurance is only available to military members, veterans, and their families, but they consistently rank high for customer service and claims handling.
AAA insurance is solid if you’re already a member and want bundling discounts. Direct Auto Insurance Company focuses on drivers who need SR-22 filing or have credit challenges. Each company uses different formulas to calculate your rate, which is why the same driver can get quotes that vary by hundreds of dollars.
That’s the whole point of shopping multiple carriers. Your age, credit score, driving record, zip code, and even your job title can make you a preferred customer with one company and a higher risk with another. We figure out which company views you most favorably and gets you the best rate without sacrificing coverage quality.
Switching insurance companies won’t hurt your credit. Insurance quotes are soft inquiries, not hard pulls, so they don’t affect your credit score. Some carriers do check your credit as part of underwriting, but that’s not the same as applying for a loan—it doesn’t ding your score.
As for coverage gaps, we make sure there aren’t any. When we switch your policy, we set the new effective date to match your current policy’s expiration or cancellation date. There’s no lapse in coverage, and you’re never driving uninsured.
We also handle the cancellation of your old policy if you want us to. You don’t have to call your old company or worry about getting a refund for unused premium—we take care of that. The whole process is designed to be seamless. You shouldn’t have to do anything except review the new policy and give us the green light to bind it.
Nothing. You don’t pay us a fee to shop your insurance or manage your policies. We get paid a commission by the insurance company when you buy a policy, the same way a captive agent does. The difference is that we’re not locked into one company, so we can actually find you the best deal.
Your rate is the same whether you buy directly from the carrier or through us. Insurance companies set their rates and file them with the state—agents can’t mark them up or discount them on their own. So if Progressive quotes you $1,200 for six months, that’s what you’ll pay whether you buy it online, through a call center, or through our agency.
The benefit of using us is that you get personalized service, ongoing support, and access to dozens of companies in one conversation. If your rate goes up next year, we can re-shop it. If you need to file a claim, we help you through the process. That’s all included at no extra cost to you.
Call us immediately. Getting non-renewed after a claim is more common than it should be, especially in Arizona where weather-related claims are frequent. The good news is that you have options—you’re not stuck without coverage.
We work with multiple carriers who specialize in insuring people who’ve been dropped by other companies. Some of them don’t penalize you as heavily for filing legitimate claims. We’ll pull quotes from our entire network, explain why you were non-renewed (sometimes it’s not even about your claim—it’s about the company pulling out of certain zip codes), and get you placed with a carrier that will actually keep you.
Time matters here. If your policy is being cancelled, you usually have 30 to 60 days’ notice. Don’t wait until the last week to start shopping. The sooner we start, the more options we’ll have and the better rate we can find. We’ve handled hundreds of these situations—it’s fixable, but you need to act quickly.
Other Services we provide in Litchfield Park